There has been much discussion about Content Filtering in the context of Glow Futures or GlowPlus recently. Some commentators suggest that the reason LA’s apply content filters is more about traffic shaping than blocking access to content for safety reasons.
see also http://www.ruachonline.org.uk/blog/?p=690
This leads to wholesale blocks on some internet services which contain useful content in the context of teaching and learning.
- It is much easier/takes less effort to block access to www.youtube.com than is it is to block access to specific known “bad” videos on the service.
- It also easier to block (or fail to open) access to the ports needed to support an interactive service like video conferencing etc.
I can remember the pain of convincing Scottish Local Authority IT support people that it was OK to open a number of ports to enable the original Glow Meet application – Marratech. Concerns there were about the risks associated with opening these ports as they may used by network hackers for other harmful purposes. I also recall at the time how some LA technical staff had insufficient knowledge about how to configure their firewalls to allow certain type of traffic through etc. This took place approximately 7 years ago, I do hope that things are better today?
Youtube is one example (there are others but I choose youtube as an illustration) of a service which definitely contains useful content for education and also supports the capability of users to easily publish video material which is designed to support teaching and learning objectives. But this is also a service which is generally blocked by many/most Scottish Local Authorities. I think it is fair to say that the justification for blocking video content is a concern about the impact that video material can have on the network service. Video needs bandwidth and can lead to a position where the network becomes more congested and end user response times deteriorate as a result.
I recall one case where an online work experience simulation had been created which made extensive use of video. In order to make this available to all Scottish Schools a decision was made to host the servers in a Central Data Centre. Schools could then run the simulation on network connected desktops. Schools typically wanted to do this as a class activity with 15 – 30 students accessing the simulations at any given time. Pupils could explore a number of specific work place scenarios and view videos of workers talking about their work etc…. This led to a situation where the school network up link became congested and response times became unacceptable. This problem was resolved by pre-positioning the videos on a school based content server – upgrading the bandwidth on the school up link was not a short term option (from memory, I believe that the school concerned had a 2 Meg synchronous link at the time which performed well in other circumstances). So finally the video traffic was contained with in the network. It is easy to see from this example that concerns about the effects of video traffic are justified.
I take the view that responsible use of the internet is now an essential life skill and further that is should be a curricular objective help learners develop a high degree of “network maturity”. This would make users more informed about the potential of the internet whilst at the same time informing them about the risks that it brings. Learners should also develop a high standard of net etiquette in the same way that we try to teach them life skills that make them good citizens in the offline world. For this reason I hold to the view that the internet as we see it from home should also be available in schools – access to this should rightly given to pupils in a gradual manner – with less filtering being applied as the use develops his/her “network maturity”.
But this does pose a real concern about the current regime which leads to this discussion in the first place. In order to provide a service in schools which is fit for purpose we need to ensure that the school network and its uplink are appropriately provisioned to support the whole range of content sources that need to be accessed – and this I believe includes service such as YouTube.
So the challenge is to adequately provide LANs and network connections to schools which have sufficient bandwidth to cope with the routine daily needs of pupils and teacher alike. The connections should be synchronous and non blocking – the actual amount of bandwidth provide should be such that it can support daily usage patterns. Communication technologies like ADSL – or even ADSL + are not right for schools in my view (I have expressed this view many time before) we should look for multi-megabit synchronous circuits every time. Metro Ethernet services provide the sort of connectivity needed over fibre optic circuits. But let us also appreciate that LA’s are currently struggling through times of austerity so it may not be easy for them to find the funding needed to invest in the network technology which is considered to be “fit for purpose” overnight. I do not have access to current stats about school connectivity across Scotland – it may be that some schools do have adequate bandwidth to support my proposed objective even now.
Some points to consider
- Need a filter capability which is linked to the user network maturity
- Need to stop blocking services which are judged to offer useful resources for education
- Filter policies to be frive by curricular priorities – not traffic shaping concerns
- Have a mechanism to deal with abuses of the system – which can be invoked as and when necessary.
- Ensure that school LANs and up-links are fit for purpose and upgrade if necessary
