web analytics

Glow 1 to Glow 2 – preserving the a national learning platform through evolution.

Based on what is known about Glow today – it is clear that Glow as we know it will be replaced by some other service in the near future.  There is currently no hard information around about what the new Glow will consist of, but we do know that the current contract will come to an end in September 2011 – that is  less than 12 months from the time I am writing this post.  We also know that the Glow re-procurement exercise, which was started some time ago, has been stopped by the Scottish Government.  So currently there is a real possibility that there will be no Glow after the end of this school session.

I want to use this post to exercise my own thinking about how this will affect the current Glow user base.

Let me preface my comments by making a comparison between Glow and a traditional school.  Glow is a learning platform with the capacity to support up to 1.5 Million unique users with adoption increasing on a year on year basis.  I prefer to deal with the facts as I know them as opposed to  speculating on the basis of information rumor.  Glow also provides a national focus for online learning which not as some seem to think completely closed down and exclusive of the web as a whole.  Many discussions seem to confuse the impact of Local Authority internet filtering as synonymous with Glow – nothing could be further from the truth.

Pupils and teachers attend school each day and school is traditionally taken to be a place of learning.  Lots of resources are collected there which both teachers and pupils can use to deliver and enhance the learning experience.  What an outcry there would be if the government was to announce that it was stopping its involvement in curriculum development, or worst still closing down all schools in a years time and leaving the process of Education to the “free” sector.  Scotland makes a significant investment in its education system and although it’s not perfect it has certainly served Scotland’s learners well.  Of course the education system does need to evolve to remain relevant so change is inevitable.  I would assert that the government has a key role and responsibility to ensure that the education system is protected and developed in a caring and sensitive manner.  The use and development of ICT today is now embedded in our education system in my view – but I do recognize that we have some way to go before ICT is universally adopted as part of daily practice in schools.

Scotland took a very brave decision early in the last decade to establish Glow as a country wide service at a time when this was unprecedented. The technology landscape at the time was very different to the way it is today and to some extent the context did influence what could be achieved.

The cost of the Glow initiative was also very small in the context of overall spending in Education.  With an overall burget of £37.5M.  This cost was spread over the initial 5 years with payments being made only when the contractor achieved clearly defined milestones according to user account provision and service performance.  There may well be a case for altering the commercial model of Glow to recognize actual service usage.  This would lead to a situation where cost of the service would of course increase as user adoption increases.  This idea is complex and probably warrants another post dedicated to considering how this may make better sense.

Early in the Glow (SSDN) project words of Alan Kay were often quoted as follows

“The best way to predict the future is to invent it”

I believe that the Glow project was one of a number of initiatives by the Scottish Government aimed at trying to “invent” the future IT landscape for Scottish education.  This was always set against a backdrop of continuous change and evolution in the world or IT at large.  We have certainly seen a number of unexpected developments taking place which have altered peoples expectations – these include the advent of Web2.0 and the social networking revolution which were just beginning to emerge when Glow was initially being specified.

Glow is based on a national directory of users including pupils, teachers, school support workers and parents.  Establishing this directory has been possible by designing and implementing a data transfer system which allows existing school MIS data to be first cleaned up and then used to trigger the setup and alteration of user accounts in Glow.  Although this process was very difficult and complex one could argue that getting user accounts setup in the Glow directory is the easy part.  Much more difficult is getting teachers to take the opportunity to use Glow and embed it into their daily teaching practice.  There is always a group early adopters but I think that in reality the majority of teachers are overwhelmed with their current workload and for some technology adoption is a step too far.

A critical issue here is the type of support that teachers are given – it is useful to note that the majority of the Glow budget was apportioned to teacher support – not the platform systems.  It was always recognized that helping the teaching profession to adapt their attitude towards and knowledge of using technology in the context of classroom practice was a key element.  This goes much further than just giving instruction of how to operate and application and is also about how the application can be used effectively to improve the learner experience.

For me it is critical that any transition from the current position to the next must be managed in a way that brings existing users onboard.  The move to the next system should be perceived as an evolution where users can easily adapt in easy stages.  I believe that a fundamental requirement here should be that existing users should be able to continue to access the platform using their existing user identifier (UID) and password (PWD).  Things like email address should be preserved as they currently are and of course the current investment in content – both nationally provide and user created – must also be preserved.

In closing I should also state that I recognize that some elements of Glow need to change but on the following basis.

  • It is essential that the move forward takes into account any lessons learned from the experience of deploying and using Glow to date.
  • We should develop the good and remove/replace/enhance the elements which are judged to be weak in a planned and staged manner.

 

Evolution not Revolution is the way forward.

9 thoughts on “Glow 1 to Glow 2 – preserving the a national learning platform through evolution.”

  1. Hi Jim,
    Very much agree with all of this.
    Having spent a lot of hours over the past month or two trying to unravel various bits of account details (with the help of a great team at glow support). I don’t t think many o the office staff in our schools would complain if the process for updating glow with Seemis data and moving accounts in and out of schools was simplified. Again I’ve no idea how this could be done.
    I’ve also noticed the sighs of many folk when telling them glow will change. These have often been the early adopters who have built up resources and practise involving glow. The very folk who will hopefully be starting to use the new system. Very important not to discourage them by losing resources. Optimally their resources would move into an easier to use new system. We will still need more training and with less resources this time.

  2. O would I love to have a more detailed interaction about this – but alas I am no longer involved in the project. I do care about what those responsible for Glow do with it – I am actually very proud of what we achieved in establishing Glow in the first place. I would not want to be seen as trying to preserve the past for no good reason – we have to move on and the right way is to evolve and most importantly identify the lessons we need to address from experience. I am very concerned that some people are spending a lot of effort in the context of Glow talking about things like internet filtering which has nothing to do with Glow – that is a Local Authority policy matter.
    I seriously feel that Scotland does need to take stock and then take work to improve in a gradual and carefully stages manner – I had thought that this was what Glow Futures was all about!. The last thing our teachers and pupils need is for the carpet to be pulled from beneath their feel at this stage.

  3. As an early adopter of Glow and ICT coordinator championing Glow to other staff in school I am very worried about its future. As a school we have invested a lot of time and effort to embed Glow in our everyday practices. It would certainly dishearten staff if all their hard work and resources were lost. Glow has had its problems and is only now starting to show the potential it promised. It would be a shame to pull the rug from under it now.

    1. I take your point. When Glow was conceived there was a view shared by the team that it would indeed take time for Glow to be established and then embedded in classroom practice. I fact some of us felt that it would take at least the first contract to get to this point. There are a couple of things that made it difficult and these are not, in my view, only restricted to the feature and quality of Glow its self. Getting teachers to see the value of adopting Glow is also some thing that for many will require a bit of a culture shift and that always takes time. Teachers need to be nurtured and supported to get to get bast the tipping point and some clearly had achieved this. But I think that leadership is also a critical factor.
      I have observed form a distance a local primary school where there was no prioty to make more use of Glow and ICT in particular – but a change of head teacher this has already changed.
      But there are still problems – such as classroom assistants have not had their Glow accounts issued – or still see ICT as options and some that they dont need to do!!! In this same school the real ambassidor for Glow and ICT is a classroom assistant – I am not saying this is a bad thing of course.

      I think we need to stick with this and address the platform issues to over come any technical impedements to allow staff to manage better. I have no illusions – some of the tools need to be replaced whilst others can be tweeked. To abandon the platform at this early stage would be a big mistake in my view.

  4. For me, a critical statement within this thoughtful piece is this:

    “There is always a group early adopters but I think that in reality the majority of teachers are overwhelmed with their current workload and for some technology adoption is a step too far.”

    I fully agree with the workload point but somewhat disagree with the adoption point.

    Most teachers are au fait with a range of platforms outside of school so I don’t think adoption of technology is really the problem. In its current form GLOW is, I feel, clunky and outdated. There’s no getting away from it – it needs honest appraisal and action to address the weaknesses within to make it more intuitive, easier to navigate and thus more user friendly. Teachers love things which work – we don’t have time for things that don’t. When something works, teachers themselves will spread the word faster than any formal mentoring or CPD approach. It only takes a couple of log ons full of gremlins and glitch moments to switch a user off to any platform.

    GLOW was a fantastic concept but the reality was/is far from perfect and ordinary users ( unlike guests attending the Stirling event, who probably have a level of proficiency far in excess of the Joe Bloggs majority of teachers ) need to be genuinely consulted to ensure the next evolution addresses the weaknesses which led to confusion, frustration and/or disengagement. Too much has been invested in GLOW in terms of money, time, expertise, and passion for us to abandon it now. Get a focus group of ‘lowest common denominator’ teachers to say how they would like GLOW to be improved and the bells and whistles element can come later.

    Scotland is famed for the original Enlightenment and I believe that we are on the cusp of the digital equivalent.

    1. I think that I mostly agree with your points Karen. The “clunky” criticisim is I think accepted by most. But this is also a question of taking a measured response. For me we need to be careful not to loose the vision of a national learning platform and all the benefits this can bring. I do feel that the current position is very worrying – there is now a real risk that time will run out there will be no possibility of a smooth transition to the next version – what ever that may be. I also worry that if the transition is not planned we will loose the benefit of all the hard work that has been done by some many. From my stand point a core goal should be to main stability for end users and refine and improve. I have no difficultly with bringing in alternative tools as long as they continue to be accessible via SSO which is the Glue that binds the the whole system together ( and of course this has already been done successfully). I also believe that the main portal needs to be refreshed. Glow is a modular design and was also conceived to be so. For this reason it is ready made for evolution. That said we need an organisation which can bring the technical effort to bear – assuming we dont have a “big IT” organisation doing this – who will? To have completed the now abandoned re-procurement would have answered a lot of my concerns with a number of IT companies thinking long and hard how to address the ICT needs of Scottish Education now and in the near future.

      We must in my view continue to have this discussion.

      1. Hi again Jim

        I agree further discussion is essential. A measured response to fresh challenges is always the best but is seldom the first one given. I’m watching the development of a national education ICT strategy with great interest. Let’s hope that common sense prevails and that, following this audit and consultation process, we achieve the perfect balance between Keep – Stop – Start and that those tasked with the leadership and management of this next evolutionary stage of GLOW are fit for the role.

  5. Hi Jim
    As a recent convert to twitter and other social media I stumbled on your blog, and a good number of others on this topic in the past week whilst ‘researching’ social media as an educational tool. As someone who has only been in the teaching game for 8 years what I can attest to is your comment “…teachers are overwhelmed with their current workload and for some technology adoption is a step too far” hits the nail on the head. And that’s a shame as a little time taken to understand can be paid back tenfold in time and stress saved later. Another factor, alluded to in other blogs, is the bewildering number of passwords we need, I’m currently on 10 (ten). I know from speaking with colleges that this is a massive put-off for those less IT savvy – and bear in mind we’re not supposed to write them down! I realise I’m preaching to the converted here, but we need more joined up thinking and a dose of common sense. I’m no IT expert, just a user, but the level of password protection seems ludicrous. Why do my pupils need a login name and password to get on line and another set of ridiculous complexity to get into Glow to retrieve homework? But this is small beer to what I’ve witnessed in the passed 8 year, namely; multiple agendas all pulling in different direction and all claiming to have the best interest of the pupil at heart. Until you get all (Government, LAs, SMT, Unions, teachers, IT support – particularly IT support – and parents) on board not even HAL9000 will solve the problem.
    Love what you guys are doing (trying to do!), all power to your elbow and never stop believing – the truth is out there.

    1. Thanks for your comment Gareth.

      Having a national coordinated strategy is right on in my view. I can see no realy value for having a situation where different agencies are developing parallel agendas. I think that Glow, as a bucket of services, can provide access to a number of complemetary services and should be a core focus in this context.
      I recall the good work done to integrate the CPD portal with the Glow SSO service – I think we need more of this. I also believe that a key requirement here is to extend the reach of the SSO service to include not only publicly funded resources but also commercial ones. Glow support for Federated Authentication through the United Kingdom Access Management Federation was introduced as a core design feature. But his is something that needs to be pushed forward agressively. I expect you will know that other resources like SCRAN and SCHOLAR as also accessible this way.

      These things do need to be reviewed and appraised to ensure that they are still the right mechanisms in the light of our ever changing ICT landscape. I stongly believe that the right way to achieve this is to hold on to the good that has been achived and refine/replace/remove other the components as necessary.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.