web analytics

Wireless Roaming for Scottish Education users.

Note: this post concerns the provision of a facility that will allow users to benefit from wireless access whilst attending council or school sites – I intend to discuss internet filtering in a subsequent post.

I want to start this post by quoting Charlielove.org as follows

“And the most useful input of the whole day? From the pupils and they said what I (and many others) have been saying for a long time: allow open and free access to Wi-Fi for all devices, allow them to connect and allow learners the same freedom in school as they have at home, in McDonalds, in Cafe Nero etc. etc.”

He goes on to say

“Why are local authorities terrified of this? It isn’t rocket science to configure a Wi-Fi network so that the corporate infrastructure is hidden from the person just connecting to access the web.  Maybe it’s because we need investment in the links between schools and the national Interconnect because LAs are concerned that the network can’t cope with the traffic levels?”

http://charlielove.org/?p=6580 click here for the full quote in context.

The following comments are set against my own experience of trying to establish a system for this in Scotland starting with LTScotland – sadly, I failed at the first hurdle.

The need for pervasive WiFi access seems to be a recurring issue for users in today’s IT landscape were wireless connectivity is very often free at the point of use (yes indeed many hotels do make charges still).  As a frequent international traveler I know that I now instinctively look for a wireless connection for my laptop at every stop.  Most places I visit have such a facilit although it is not always free!  I also have an iPASS account which allows me to access paid WiFi services with all costs being passed to my centralized the iPass account.

The purpose of this post is to present some thinking about how wireless access can be made a reality for school users in Scotland.  I have seen the need for Wireless connectivity raised a few times during the course of the Glow Future debate.  This is nothing new, for many years there has been discussion around the need to support the connection of personal devices to school (or institutional networks in general).  By devices here I include smart phones, pads, net books and of course laptops.  Portable computing devices are now owned by an increasing proportion of users it seems to me that the time is right to include access to the learning platform from mobile devices on an any time any where basis to be a basic requirement.  I consider schools to be in scope in the context of my previous statement.

This same issue that was considered when Glow was first conceived but that general view at the time was that mobile devices were still in the minority and first priority should be given to supporting institutional owned equipment and personal devices connecting from the home. Hence the primary emphasis on support for desktop and laptop computers etc.

Why should School WLANs not be opened up to personal mobile devices?

Its all about trust in my view.  If we allow access then we have a situation where any user (with no connection with teaching and learning) can connect – this would include any person within range of the school wifi network.  I trust that I do not need to develop that line of thinking further at this point – I think that the implications are quite clear.

It’s really the use (and optionally the users devices) that need to be validated.  So my starting point here is that any authorized user should be able to connect-provided that the user as been pre-authorized the network owner (school or local authority).  We should also add to this primary set of user the concept of trusted visitors – ie users who have been authorized by other trusted schools.

If such a system was in place we increase access for all school users and it would be possible to extend the range of available hot spots to include other public places including libraries, hospitals and FE and HE institutions.  So what is proposed here is to put in place a WiFi roaming arrangement that provides pupils and school staff with the ability to connect wirelessly using either school owned devices or their own devices.

Where a user wants to use his/her own device it would optionally be possible to expect that the device meets certain basic standards in relation to virus protection etc. – this would need to be confirmed before the device would be allowed to connect to the network.

Any user who is known and trusted by any co-operating group of schools ( other organizations ) should be able to connect to the wireless network at any of the schools and other premises by authenticating using their user ID and password.  Such a system can formally be described as federated access control allow that would grant any authorized and trusted user access anywhere throughout all the federated locations.

The level of service being offered could be restricted based on the credentials of the user and their role.

None of what I have described above is new in concept but currently I am not aware that any such facility exists in any Scottish Schools.

How can this be achieved practically?

One approach is to setup a new wireless roaming federation for this purpose.  It would be necessary to have all schools (perhaps via their Scottish Local Authorities) to join this federation.  This will involve a great deal of effort.

An alternative route would be to join an existing federation.  For this purpose I would propose that there is a ready made solution called EduRoam (see link at and of post).  In an ideal world, every Scottish school would join EduRoam and this would have the effect of allowing authenticated access any schools wireless network with the option of granting full or partial access to the network and related service.  Of course the decision about how much access users are given will rest with the school ( or Local authorities)  I would however suggest that if there are basically two levels of access which are full and internet only that would suffice for all users types.

What would this look like in practice?

Imagine a situation where a pupil arrives at school, opens up his/her personal laptop the following demonstrates how this might work.
1               Pupils open laptop
2               Attempt to join wireless network
3               User challenged for UID and PWD
4               User it authenticated against his home authentication system
(which could be a school, LA or national system)
5               User is granted access to the network with appropriate rights.

Where the user is a visitor, the user will effectively given what is equivalent to a standard route to the internet, no more no less.  This route my well be restricted and internet safety filter to ensure that the connection cannot be abused etc.

Could this be done today?

Clearly there is a need to enter into an agreement with EduRoam to use such a service.  This could be done in a number of ways including at the national, regional (LA) and school level.  Practically, it would be ideal if this was done at national level.

School wireless network would need to be quality assured and the accompanying network admission system checked to ensure that it can support a federated authentication approach.

EduRoam uses a RADIUS based system to facilitate user authentication and network admission which sends authentication requests back to a users home authority (which could be Glow in the context of the scenario outlined here)  The EduRoam site provides an excellent description of how this works – note that the video on the front page is HE centric.  I suppose we need to use imagination to see how this might work in a Scottish schools environment.

www.eduroam.org

 

2 thoughts on “Wireless Roaming for Scottish Education users.”

  1. Interesting, but surely from a virus perspective it is the network itself that should have virus protection.

    Relying on a mish mash of user installed AV solutions will still lead to issues, having a reliable solution (a la Glow) for network based AV is in my opinion preferable.

  2. Hi again David,
    I was not really trying to deal with network security in this post but this is something that I do plan to write about soon. I agree with your point the network its self should be source of protection. In ideal world we would have a consistent approach to network provision and security that trancends all parts of Scotland. This raises another issue I also plan do write about. Allowing “unknown” devices to connect to the wireless networks clearly raises significant concerns and that is a big topic in its self. One advantage of the EduRoam approach is that the connected visitor is connected to a VLAN which leads only to the Internet. More of this later!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.