web analytics

Learner Entitlement – relevant to #Glowplus, #EDUScotICT, #ICTEx ?

In my last post I wrote about the concept of Internet Proficiency for Learners and Teachers- see here.

It seems to me that in that post I suggested that GlowPlus should facilitate the progress of young learners from a starting point of being a novice through to being a advanced Internet user.  With this passage comes a gradual move from operating in a very resticted online world to the Advanced state where the learner has full access to the internet.

So how does the concept of internet filtering apply in this situation?  I think the current position in Scotland is one where the Local Authority applies a set of filters which can prevent access by school users to content and service which may be generally accessible from home/non LA internet access services.  I am not about recommend that LAs need to abandon their general approach to interent content filtering – I think that would be wreckless.  I do however want to suggest that when a user achieves Advanced Status that they will enjoy access to the Internet from schools which is much less restricted that may be the case today. This implies that we have a situation where Intenet filter policies need to be responsive to agreed learner/teacher needs.

Coupled with this, there is also a need to ensure that in order for the learner to have access to a much wider range of content than is the case today that LAs will need recognise and be able to meet the increased demands on bandwidth.  This implies that schools will need to have improved bandwidth on the path between the desktop and the Internet.

When considering how Schools and LAs provide appropriate access to online resources, from what ever source, I believe that there is a need to improve on the current situation.  We hear so many reports of pupils and teachers being denied access to many online resources which are considered to be useful in a range of curricular contexts.  So this raises the general point of Learner Entitlement in realtion to access to online resources.  It will be necessary to first agree what this translates to in terms of what services and content need to be accessible and then to apply what is agreed across the country.

I attended the NEN 2012 conference last week where a paper was tabled dealing with his issue.  See the following documents which have been evolved over a few years and which deal with a range of entitlement issues.  Interestingly, these documents were written collabouratively with input from the English RBC/LAs, Wales, Northern Ireland and of course Scotland.  I think these documents are worth reviewing to see what they have to offer in relation to the developing debate and work of the ICT Excellence group relating to GlowPlus.

A short flyer which summarised the main issues
http://www.nen.gov.uk/media/259/supporting-the-learner-entitlement.html

A two page overview of the National Education Network
http://www.nen.gov.uk/media/260/nen-the-education-network-vision.html

Future Learning – the Learners Entitlement
The paper which was tabled at the NEN Conference 2012 – which is based on work does previously with input from a range of organisations including BECTa – this is a work in progress.
http://www.nen.gov.uk/media/262/future-learning-the-learners-entitlement.html

Building A Broadband Entitlement
A much more detailed paper which deals with a range of issues in relation to the infrastrure needed for connecting the user with the online resources needed. This paper starts to deal with some of the issues which can become a focus for complaint such as lack of bandwidth.  We realistically need to acknowledge that the provision of infrastructure must be provisioned to have the capability to scale as time passes.
http://www.nen.gov.uk/media/148/nen-publication-building-a-broadband-entitlement.html

Internet Proficiency – some thoughts #EDUScotICT, #GlowPlus, #ICTEx

This is something that I have had on my mind for some time, after a discussion with Theo Kuechel yesterday, I felt the need to commit my thoughts on this to paper!  So here goes…….

I want to compare life “on the internet” to life in the traditional real world – pre-internet days.  Today we take for granted a whole raft of services which are ever more easily accessible through our computers and a host of other devices like smart phones, tablets and other hand held devices.  Access to online services has moved from being occasional to always available  – our young people have this capability from an early age with many primary school children being given their first computer/phone.  Being “connected” in todays society is being a “must have” for a large proportion of todays young people.

As a child I was given my first two wheeled bicycle when I was around 7 years old.  It was too large for me – but that was deliberate to take account of the fact that I was still growing.  My dad fitted wooden blocks to the pedals so I could reach them and this provided the necessary compensation to get me started.  Stabilizers were fitted and I was able to ride it almost straight away.  I fondly recall a serious of lessons/training sessions after the stabilizers were removed when my dad taught me how to ride it solo.  He would hold the bicycle upright, walking alongside, as I would pedal it and try to keep my balance – as I gained confidence I would pedal a little faster whilst dad ran along side still holding me upright.  This carried on until one night he was running alongside but, unknown to me, was no longer holding on…..  I was away 😉  That opened a door of independence for me and allowed me to cycle to places and travel distances that I could not get to on foot.  Dad did also explain the basics of cycling safety – like which side of the road to stick to and how to always stop at road junctions, and more.  I still to this day remember his aid memoir about knowing which side of the road to cycle on – this was to make sure that bell ( fixed to the left side of the handlebar) was always close to the pavement side…….  Seems obvious, but that stuck with me and I always instinctively checked that this was the case before setting off.

A couple of years later I took the “Cycling Proficiency” course and test at school which resulted in me having a certificate which confirmed that I had gained certain knowledge and demonstrated certain cycling skills.

So how can this relate to the Internet?

Seems to me that there is a comparison to be made in that children today are exposed to the internet on an almost hourly basis either via a computer or smart hand held device.  The percentage of children having this capability will be ever greater and I sense that the age of introduction is becoming ever younger.  We have heard the term “Digital Native” and I do really believe that todays young generation are very aptly described by this term.

I think that there is a case for providing children with a staged exposure to the internet whilst ensuring that they collect the necessary skills to be good internet citizens and also to remain as safe as possible.  Children will be exposed to all that the internet has to offer at home, of this there is no doubt, parents will to different degrees facilitate this.  Sometimes children will have access enabled by parents and then be left to their own devices.

I think that there is a case for the country Education system to take some responsibility for ensuring that children have a staged exposure to the internet as a whole and that at the end of this process children be trusted to publish and interact all internet tools.  This should be of course done in the relative safety of the GlowPlus environment, but how might this be achieved.

I propose the idea of having an “Internet Proficiency” scheme which could adopted across the country.  Schools would be encouraged to deploy the scheme where pupils would be introduced to a number of “good behaviours” and “safety awareness issues”.  The scheme might have up to three levels of competence as follows, Novice, Intermediate, Advanced ( Bronze, Silver, Gold ) with all pupils starting at the Novice level as soon as they are introduced to the Internet ( online world )  in any form.  I further suggest that these classifications are include as a core part of the GlowPlus Authentication system and service.

Pupils accessing Glow as a Novice user might have a very restricted scope in terms of who they can interact with.  Perhaps this would be initially restricted to their parents ( parents need to participate in this scheme – its not just a school thing!), their class members, teacher and any classroom support workers working with them.  Progressing to Intermediate level, a pupils capability to interact would be extended to include all classes in his/her school and perhaps also other schools in the LA to which the schools belongs.  Gold level would effectively open the door on the Internet as a whole.

Some examples – email addressing capability would grow as the pupil moves through the grades, blog posts would initially be restricted to only the pupils own class but as their level increases their blogs will be increasingly exposed until they can be seen and commented ( subject to moderation ) on by internet users at large.

A key point here is that if such a system were to be introduced, the Glowplus service should be able to support it through controlling the level of exposure that pupils posts and other communications are granted.  There would also be a facility for withdrawing or demoting to a lower level if the pupil abuses the service in some way.

How soon can a pupil progress to Advanced level?  In my view this should be influenced by the pupils achievements and performance.  I do not mean to suggest that a pupil needs to wait till they are at Secondary school before their posts can be seen on the internet at large – I see no reason that a pupil should be prevent from being an Advanced user at some stage of their Primary school education.  The decision to award an upgrade of status should be made my staff / parents at the local school.  Perhaps when a pupil demonstrates competency’s that equate to an Advanced user the teacher and parent will have the capability switch the pupils status from Intermediate to Advanced.  Note that I see some value in involving parents in this grading process – after all we need parents to reinforce good behaviours when pupils are online and out of school.

Pupils could also have badges added to their profile according their current status.

I recognise that there will be a need to define the “levels” in a way that they can be allocated consistently throughout the country – but I think that this will be a topic for another post.

One other passing concern – we need a profession of capable and competent internet ready teachers to administer this system – I wonder what the general state of readines is that that regard?  Perhaps we also need to similar scheme for teachers????

 

Glow – “a walled garden” – #GlowPlus #EDUScotICT #SLF2012

I attended the SLF 2012 last week – it seems to have been scalled down compared to previous years but there were still very good opportunities for networking and of course a diverse seminar program.  It was good to renew old acquaintances and catch-up with old colleagues.

I was not able to attend the round-table discussion which was entitled “Do we need a national ‘intranet’ “   but was able to review the recording of it which is published below.

http://edutalk.cc/do-we-need-a-national-intranet

It is an interesting exchange of views which was I was keen to listen to.  Most of the people involved seemed to be active teachers – its always interesting to hear views and opinions from people who are at the “chalk face”.

During the discussion and not for the first time, I heard the term “Walled Garden” used to describe Glow – (originally called the SSDN Intranet).  But I feel this an inappropriate term to describe the current service.  The impression given that Glow is a Walled Garden is based, I believe, on a flawed understanding of what does and does not constitute the Glow service.

I first heard the term Walled Garden back when Education Service Providers (ESP) first started to offer Internet connectivity to schools back in the 1990’s.  Companies including BT and RM (there were many others) who were early on the ESP scene would use the term Walled Garden as a reassurance to schools and LA’s that the service they offered was safe and full of content that had been validated to be suitable for children to use.  The ESP’s would provide a feed to schools (often based on modem (9.6 – 16 baud) and later ISDN (64 – 128 kbps) connectivity) which provided access to content they had provided and also a subset of content which was available on the public internet.  Internet content was surveyed and validated before it was considered safe to include it in the walled garden.   The term Walled Garden implied that the “stuff” on the inside was OK to use and what was on the outside may or may not have been acceptable.  At the time this generally seemed to be a welcome development and schools/teachers/LA’s were happy to use the service.  There would be a service available to teachers who could nominate new content they had discovered as being both useful and acceptable – these items would then added the walled garden.

When the SSDN Interconnect was introduced early in the 2000’s, Scottish LA’s were faced with a need, some for the first time, to implement and maintain their own Internet filters for education users.  On the face of it, this meant they needed to build their own walled garden as opposed to having this done by an ESP.

The JANET (Joint Academic NETwork) network on which the SSDN Interconnect was built  was basically an extension of the internet and as such provides a path to the any content which is available on the internet – JANET provided the core network for the SSDN Interconnect and also a route to the Internet.  At this time, existing users of JANET – Universities and Research Institutions, provided some degree of filtering at their point of connection to JANET.  The Internet includes various content types including static web pages, content repositories, online databases, email transit and of course many other rich types of content including audio and video.  The general model of connectivity was that the LA took a SSDN Interconnect feed at its HQ then passed on connectivity to the Internet for its schools ( the primary service users of the interconnect) via is own Wide Area Network (WAN).  When Glow was introduced it was build at a data centre which was also directly connected to the SSDN Interconnect

Without any filter service this would mean that school users could access any content on the internet and schools could access services with broadband content  (such as YouTube which was a new service when Glow was being procured) which could consume large amounts of bandwidth and degrade the performance for all users of the internet service as the WAN became congested.  LA’s generally used their internet filters (typically setup at the point where the LA network connected to the SSDN Interconnect) to protect the network resource from abuse and overuse.

Getting back to the title of this post!  When the term “walled garden” is used to describe Glow,   I believe that this is a misuse of the term and leads to a mistaken impression of what Glow provides and is “responsible” for.

What Glow is:
Glow (the SSDN Intranet ) is a trusted  and Authenticated service  which offers through a single sign on system access to a number of services which are free at the point of use to all users.

the available services are as follows:

Account provisioning system, Web Portal, Email service, User Groups (hierarchical structure), Video/Audio publishing service, Web Site publishing service (internal to Glow or to the Internet), Desktop Conferencing (with Audio & Video), Chat (Glow chat for children and MSN Messenger for Teachers), National Directory,  Discussion Forums, Blogs, e-Portfolios, Calendars, Email Distribution List Service, Secure File Transfer, Cook Books (online instructional manuals)

Notice that filtering is not included in this list!

I may have missed some services but from memory these are the “core” services which are (or were available since Glow was introduced) available to all school users in Scotland according to their role and Glow group membership.  All user accounts are provisioned from School MIS systems which are considered to be a reliable and trusted sources of user credentials.

Glow is also described as a closed system – I preferred to use the term Authenticated.  Glow never was closed or filtered.  It is perfectly possible any authorized user to identify a good resource on the internet and link it into the glow environment.  As a web based service it was intended from day one that this would be possible and I believe that this is possible today.  If a resource cannot be accessed by a user whilst currently logged into Glow via a LA LAN/WAN this is due to the filter policies that the LA has applied to its Internet feed.  It is equally true that such a resource when linked to a Glow resource will be accessible when a user access’s their internet account from a non-LA location.

I feel that it is very important that any discussion about the use of ICT in support of Scottish Education be based on fact and is not muddied by red herrings.  Statements like “Glow is a Walled Garden” are no more than “red herrings” in my view.  See what I have said earlier on the general topic of Internet Filtering – which  another aspect of ICT in schools which does in my view need to be considered and acted on!

http://www.ruachonline.org.uk/blog/?p=714

 

 

Upper Donside – Joint Service – Grampian Motor Museum – Alford

Sunday 16th September 2012, I was involved in a church outdoor service at the Grampian Motor Museum. Annually, the Upper Donside group of church’s arrange a joint service and these are held outdoor, weather permitting!.  It is quite a project with the need to identify a venue and then to set it up, it is planned over a number of months.  This service took place at the Grampian Motor Museum Track where the congregation sat in the stand and the band/speakers used a curtain sided trailer.

See the photo below which was taken whilst the venue was being setup.

The theme was “Bespoke Ministry” and the speakers were Adrian and Bridget Plass.  Adrian has written many books and poems which look at current Christian church practices with a serious but humourious commentary.  The service was recorded on a hand held MP3 recorder and published in the Kemnay Church podcast at the following link.

http://www.kemnaykirk.org.uk/html/services.html#Radio

Andrew May Duthie (Andy) – a potted history!

(I wanted to share this article about my late uncle which I was asked to write for publication in some local news papers in the Scottish Borders and Fraserburgh – his home town)

Mr Andrew May Duthie known affectionately to his friends as Andy – passed away Saturday 25th August 2012

Andy Duthie, originally from Fraserburgh in the North East of Scotland, came with his wife Jean and their young daughter Ruth to Galashiels in 1958.  Their family was complete when David was born in 1959 after they had moved into a house in Waverlay Place, Netherdale.

His first career choice was to be a joiner so he served his time working with Hall and Robertson in Fraserburgh.  Subsequently, he pursued his passion to work with young people and so attended the Teacher Training College in Aberdeen to become a teacher of Technical Subjects.  He taught PE at Cairnbulg Primary School for a short time and it was there that he was reaquanted Jean Findlay who was a primary teacher.  They married at Fraserburgh Baptist Church on 28th July 1956.

Andy was to spend his entire teaching career at Galashiels Academy.  He was promoted to Principle Teacher of Guidance which allowed him to focus more on helping pupils make career choices and also work through challenging and sometimes difficult social situations.  His great passion was to help them to develop into young adults and his work as a guidance teacher fulfilled this for him.   Mr Duthie would often be seen with his briefcase in hand hurrying from one part of the school to another – this earned him the nick name Speedy (as in Speedy Gonzales).  He continued to work as a teacher of technical subjects and was involved in setting up the ROSLA courses, an initiative to provide vocational input for pupils who were not so attracted to study academic subjects.

At the head teacher’s request Andy, already a scout set up a new troup at Galashiels Academy.  This he did willingly, giving his own time to get the 4th Gala Troup operational.  Every year he organized the Scout camp which would see the group members camping at places including Loch Goilhead, Loch Earn and Arran where Andy would supervise various constructional projects such as raft and bridge building.  He was a key personality in the Scottish Borders Scouting movement and latterly was District Scout Master before retiring from that after many years of service.  Scouting Principles and the Scout Law were very important factors in Andy’s life and this, along with his Christian faith did much to make the man he became.  Andy took his work as a Scouter very seriously and held to the view that the activities were more than just time fillers and actually provided an environment which afforded those involved, opportunities for character building and being more effective team players.

Jean and Andy worshiped at the Victoria Street Baptist Church where he was to serve as a deacon for many years.  He was involved in the process of merging the Stirling Street and Victoria Street Baptist churches when the individual churches were judged to be unsustainable.  He would also give of his own time to help maintain the church building doing joinery work with some support from other willing members.  For this he gladly gave of his time.

Andy retired in 1994, four years after Jean, and both enjoyed many years together at their home – Craigpark House in Galashiels where they lived for 35 years in total.  This house was to be a setting for many church house group meetings and barbeques.  The cellar was converted into a workshop where Andy did many projects.  He also enjoyed playing the piano accordion and painting water colours, he was a man of many talents.

Eventually, in 2003 they decided that the time was right to relocate to Bridge of Don, Aberdeen to be nearer their family and four grand children.  Their new home provided another interest for Andy and he developed various projects to make their new house more comfortable and more easily maintained. The home was within easy distance of the Bridge of Don Baptist church which they attended and made a group of close friends with whom they enjoyed regular excursions seeking out suitable coffee shops and beauty spots in and around the North East of Scotland.

Andy was a keen traveller and loved to journey to new locations. This resulted in many holidays to places beyond the UK including camping holidays in Europe and then in later life further afield to the USA and Canada.  Andy and Jean once embarked on a back-packing holiday when they travelled across the USA by train and bus.  During this holiday they were able to make contact with family members and visit locations where Jean’s ancestors had settled in the early 1900’s.  From an early stage, travel inspired Andy to learn foreign languages, including French and German and in later in life he even attempted Polish,  he was determined to communicate with people in their own language.

Despite having some health issues and his deteriorating hearing, Andy maintained a healthy interest in everything that took place around him.  He was always happy to be in company especially family gatherings and enjoyed these times immensely.  Andy was a keen TV watcher particularly of history and nature programs and liked to take charge of the remote control.  He passed away suddenly and peacefully at home with Jean and members of his family close by.

Andy will be sorely missed by Jean, the immediate family and his many friends but the legacy of his memory will remain a source of comfort for all who knew him.

 

P.S.
See other posts I published:
http://www.ruachonline.org.uk/blog/?p=652
and
http://www.ruachonline.org.uk/blog/?p=686