web analytics

Education Fast Forward Debate – EFF6 – coming soon.

I felt privileged to listen to the last EFF debate which had as it principal participants a group of young people from around the world.  You can read more about that event here EFF Debate 5 and find a link to a the recording of the whole event.

EFF 6 is now being planned when the panel will be located at George Thomas Room, Central Hall Westminster during the Education World Forum.  Put this date and time into your diary,  11am (GMT) on the 28th January 2013.  As usual the event will be conducted using Cisco Telepresence and also the video will be live streamed to the internet.  It is planned to have some of the delegates from the Education World Forum conference present with the panel so there will be event more then the usual influential and respected voices involved.

A bit more information about EFF.

Edu­ca­tion Fast For­ward (EFF), an orga­ni­za­tion, spon­sored jointly by Promethean and Cisco, that brings together lead­ing global experts and change agents from the world of edu­ca­tion to dis­cuss ‘the top­ics that mat­ter most’, wants to begin to change that by bring­ing together some artic­u­late and intel­li­gent voices from the world’s youth to dis­cuss issues that are rel­e­vant to young peo­ple them­selves and to their edu­ca­tion.

In July 2012, in the most recent of the five debates orga­nized by EFF to date, a group of elo­quent and youth­ful voices debated the topic ‘From Learner Voice to Global Peace’. The young peo­ple were located all across the globe and came together pri­mar­ily through the won­der of Telep­res­ence (TP), a high-definition video con­fer­enc­ing tech­nol­ogy. The dis­cus­sion that day was not only intel­li­gent and thought­ful: it was truly inspir­ing for every­one involved.

The full debate can be watched and lis­tened to on Promethean Planet.
And now, in Jan­u­ary 2013, dur­ing the annual Edu­ca­tion World Forum, to be held in Lon­don, another group of excep­tional young peo­ple (includ­ing some of the voiced from EFF5) will come together through the magic of TP to talk about ‘From Learner Voice to Emerg­ing Lead­ers’. Those of us involved in EFF have some hopes and expec­ta­tions of what might come out of the event, but we are also highly aware that there must be a gen­uine space in amongst our pre­sump­tions for the hopes and expec­ta­tions of the young peo­ple them­selves to come to the fore dur­ing and beyond the dis­cus­sion.

The pri­mary aim is twofold:

  • bring the voice of youth to the policy-makers’ table, to let the young peo­ple hear some views on the big issues, and to let them debate them openly and fully
  • to bring the policy-makers to the learn­ers’ table so that they have to face up to the issues that are crit­i­cal to the learn­ers before they make their pol­icy decisions

Issues such as the struc­ture of the cur­ricu­lum, how edu­ca­tion is deliv­ered (includ­ing dif­fer­ences in this across the world), the rel­e­vance of edu­ca­tion to their lives, how we might encour­age real change in the rela­tion­ships between peo­ple in edu­ca­tion sys­tems, seek­ing to realise the extra­or­di­nary value that can be sought by tack­ling education’s chal­lenges with peo­ple rather than doing it to them. We need all pol­icy mak­ers to take on board the knowl­edge that they are mak­ing deci­sions now that will affect the gen­er­a­tion ahead, and per­haps more than one gen­er­a­tion ahead.

And all of this will be hap­pen­ing across a truly inter­na­tional matrix of con­nec­tions, cross­ing coun­tries, cul­tures, and com­mu­ni­ties. I will be blog­ging again in the New Year with details of the date and time, and with infor­ma­tion about the key speak­ers, young and not-so-young, who will be lead­ing the discussion.

 

The Internet of Everything – any Glow Futures relevence #GlowPlus #EduScotICT #ICTEX

It is remarkable now information from one topic can cross-fertilise and seem to be relevant in a difference context.  This post deals with just such an occurrence which I have experienced recently.

I have been reading with interest some blogs by Dave Evans who is Chief Futurist, Innovation Practice at Cisco, the company I work for.  I think his posts are worth a read and can be accessed here.

this video is also worth the 3.14 minutes that it takes to watch

He also writes a series of 4 posts about the concept of the “Internet of Everything”.  He talks about the explosion in growth of the internet in terms of devices connected.  Already exhausted is the original addressing scheme designed for the Internet Protocol (IP) known as IP4 and the new addressing scheme, IP6 is being deployed as now.  The later opens the door for the connection of an uncomprehendable number of devices.

I would encourage any one reading this post to follow the link to Dave’s blog and read more.

This has caused me to reflect on the implications of this sort of trend for Glow.  Dave quotes some remarkable facts about not just the number of devices which will connect but the impact of their ability communicate with each other.

This has caused me to reflect on my own experience of using current social tools such as facebook, which I use daily.  I have noticed that the adverts which I am being targeted with are increasingly relevant to my interests.  Nothing amazing here and to be expected.  The facebook business model is all about having the ability to exploit what facebook knows about the people using it’s service to maximise the effectiveness of its advising operations.  I think its fairly obvious that if you push an advert about car sales toward someone that you know is getting ready to change their car they may be more likely to take notice!

Have you ever deleted an advert from your facebook home page – try it and notice the short survey you are asked to complete – which is of course gathering more information about your reason deleting the advert!  Here is the question asked before the advert is hidden.

Advert hidden

We’ll try not to show you this advert again.

Why did you hide it?

  •  Uninteresting
  •  Misleading
  •  Sexually explicit
  •  Against my views
  •  Offensive
  •  Repetitive
  •  Other

Interesting that this can be interpreted not so much in the context of the advertisement being hidden, but more about what facebook should show you in the future!  Of course you cannot totally remove the advert panel – and it will be re-populated in the future with adverts which facebook thinks are more relevant to your interests.  I guess the more you hide the more focused the adverts shown will become.

So what relevance to Glow?

Could the same principle/approach be applied to Glow in the context of improving education opportunities for learners?

Suppose that Glow had at its heart a knowledge base about its users (called the directory in the original Glow implementation) , their interests and most importantly their learning.  Suppose a learner is working on some topic but experiencing some difficulty with a concept – the system might know this because they took a test and did not perform well.  If the knowledge base has access to this fact then a consequence could be that the learner is targeted with – not adverts for commercial products – but a series of links to resources that deal with this topic/issue in question…..  Such a feature could bring some advantage to learners by helping them to see immediately relevant resource based on their current learning activities.  I agree with the concept of communities where people with like interests can get together – but we should also exploit push technologies where people can be targets with “adverts” (for want of a better word)  about resources that could overcome their current learning hurdles!

More simply if the knowledge base knows that the pupil is currently in the Maths class then we might expect the user to be targeted with Maths resources, when they enter the French class the UI could be rendered in French and so on – you can see how this approach might be developed further to the learners advantage????  The knowledge base would of course need to be updated by the second so that the system can respond in a timely manner to user needs.  Of course this approach can apply to all users – not just learners…..

I can see that it’s easy for facebook to develop its underlying knowledge base since facebook is essentially a single platform – with a number of plugins to provide additional functionality. There will always be challenges to deploying such a service when the platform is disaggregated and made up from a collection of disconnected tools.

With all of this in mind I really think that the designers of the next generation of Glow might consider much more than just the UI and Components which might be included but also to consider the value of developing and expanding the user profile to include information from the learners on going experience so that the system has the capability to identify learning issues and also to push relevant learning assets as needed.  I see some comments about making Glow more user focused – might the idea raised above be something worthy of exploration as the new platform is conceived a another entity of the Internet of Everything?  I think that this raises the case for a Core Glow service which is concerned about user identification, authorisation and accounting supplemented with a dynamic user profile.  The profile needs to be able respond to triggers associated with the learners daily activity as well as storing relatively statc data such as name, class, school etc….  Lets call this the Glow Dynamic Directory for reference purposes.

Perhaps we should consider the following title for Glow in the future – “The Glow of Everything”.

 

 

Initial response to the document a “A Digital Learning Environment for Scottish Schools” – initial thoughts.

First I would like to thank the ICTEx group for publishing their interim the paper which gives some indication of the likely outcomes of their work.

I first of all want to applaud the two fundamental notions which are listed in section 3. I have always felt that teachers take front-line responsibility for standards of education in their classroom and for this reason need to be trusted to determine which resources are appropriate for use in the classroom environment. The issue of future proofing is absolutely fundamental, I see no value in implementing a system at this stage which does not have the capability to evolve as a basic characteristic.

It is my opinion that thinking has moved on since initial discussions about Glow+ started. I am pleased to see that the committee’s work has identified a number of basic requirements which are indeed in line with many of my own thoughts on the matter. I have written a number of posts in the last year and a half in which I raised issues that I considered to be important in relation to the future Glow as a national learning platform. I’m happy to note that some of these are no embedded in the ICTEx groups current thinking. ( see here for further comment http://www.ruachonline.org.uk/blog/?p=586)

In relation to providing further constructive input to the discussions there are a few issues that I would like to raise in this post.

Authentication

It is appropriate that the need for authentication system is now properly acknowledged. I do however feel that the paper falls short in its description of the functionality that the authentication system should embody. In an earlier post I referred to an authentication system which is underpinned by an account provisioning system. In addition the source of truth for such a system must be trusted. For this reason I proposed that the current method of account provisioning be retained, at least in concept. A key element of this would be that user data comes from one trusted source which is the school MIS system. This may be accepted and understood but it does not seem to be mentioned in the paper therefore I feel the need to highlight it.  If this is not the preferred option, then the group should make clear what the alternative is. ( see here for further comment http://www.ruachonline.org.uk/blog/?p=512)

Application Services

Moving on to application services I want to endorse the concept of providing an easily accessible set of application services which are accessible through easy to use user interface. I do see one service that appears to be absent and that is any sort of social platform. Social networking today has become embedded in society and for this reason I feel that it’s essential that social networking capabilities are part of the authenticated and trusted set of services that Glow provides. ( see here for further comment http://www.ruachonline.org.uk/blog/?p=586)

Content Store

In relation to content services the proposal for a common store which can be accessed by a number of applications is highly appropriate.  Having such a store can help overcome many of the issues that were experienced early in the original Glow project in relation to content indexing and search. I sincerely hope that this fundamental change in architecture will make it possible for the introduction of what I have referred to as a universal search capability. (see here for related comment http://www.ruachonline.org.uk/blog/?p=581)

In section 15 the requirements are laid out as essential requisites for successful operation of future global environment. These can hardly be argued with and in fact seem to represent basic common sense. But it’s also important to recognise the difficulty of implementing Scotland wide policies and services, when we still have 32 different authorities which ultimately responsible for the delivery to the desktop.  Has the group considered how it will advance, or indeed enforce, a Scotland wide agreement on filtering and on open access to content and applications? The resolution of this issue or otherwise will make or break the group’s plans for Glow+.

Internet filtering is an issue that has been raised a number of times – particularly in recent weeks. Based on my previous experience and current knowledge I do feel it is appropriate that one solution could be implemented for the benefit of all Scottish education users. This will need to take account of the fact that there was a common network infrastructure used by both education users and other local authority users. So the filtering capability needs to be able to cater for diverse groups because of this situation.  See here for further comment http://www.ruachonline.org.uk/blog/?p=714

Ultimately the original vision of Glow is still relevant. That was to provide a national platform for education that could provide users the ability to access content and collaborate in order to take forward education objectives. For this reason is essential that users can be grouped based on their roles and interests. This is one area that appears to be missing from the paper. Conversations with former colleagues and people who are currently working to support ICT in Scottish education seems to indicate that Glow groups has been one of the most successful aspects of the original core portfolio of services. For this reason it should be a basic requirement going forward that these existing groups with their relates content are migrated to the new environment.

As I have stated on a number of occasions the maintenance of a continuous, but improving service is in my view a basic requirement and I hope that the committee has considered the need for a strategy to achieve this goal.  Any strategy which positions Glow+ as a project on it own with no dependencies for the current service will have the effect of taking users back to square one.  Users do need to be assured that their current investment in Glow will not be cast aside and that their content will survive any transition to the proposed platform.

Continuity in terms of content is important in the shape of resources, materials, etc – there also needs to be continuity in terms of collaborative groups already set up in Glow (and there are many of these in existence) and any websites which users have built.

Once again I want to express my gratitude for the opportunity to read this document and to offer feedback on some of the issues it raises. I intend to reflect on the content of the document father and perhaps give more detailed feedback on issues that it contains.

 

Grandeur of the Seas – Cruise after refit

Mary and I returned from our bi-annual cruise on the Grandeur of the Seas 4 weeks ago.

Here is a quote from the Royal Caribbean web site

“Why Our Cruise Ships?

Each ship in our fleet is packed with incredible features that make your journey unforgettable.“

As it happens the ship went through a refit earlier in 2012 year so our expectations were high for and enjoyable and comfortable experience.

This hope was initially dented when we boarded. We made our way straight to our cabin to drop our carry on bages before setting of to explore the ship.  Our cabin was 4070 which is located third along the corridor from the Centrum.  The Centrum is a beautiful 7 deck high atrium which was to be a focal point for many entertainment activitied throughout our 11 day cruise.  It did look very good on first impressions – but that “good feeling” lasted  no more then about 5 seconds as walked through the Centrum past the R Bar towards our cabin.  We were greeted with a quite over whelming stench of raw sewerage!  This was completely unexpected in this centre piece of grandeur ;-(

Initial feeling was that his would be a passing occurance and things would get better as  soon as we set sail.  In fact this was not to be the case and we were to experience this unwelcome smell each time we left our cabin and passed through the centrum – which we needed to do each time we left our room to engage an any activity.  There were a few occassions when the area was stench free but I would estimate that 95% of the time this unwelcome phenominum was present.

We did complain to the customer service desk and were told that many people had also done the same.  This was of no real consolation to us and there is no doubt that this had a profound negative impact on our enjoyment of our holiday which otherwise was excellent.

The Captain and First Engineer held a Q & A session in the Centrum when the matter of the stench was raised by three passengers.  We were told that the smell was caused by the installation of a new sewage treatment plant at the recent refit.  Apparently, wind direction can cause fumes from the sewage storage tanks to enter the ship – this was the cause of the effect we experienced!!!!!!!!.  My impression was that this was being passed of as  normal occurance when a new sewerage plant is installed as it takes time for “the natural bacteria in the tanks to build up to a sufficient level to process and decompose sewage matter efficiently”.  I am afraid that this lame explanation did not reassure me that things were as they should be!

If this is a “normal ” phenominum then I am afraid that I will certainly need to revise any plans for future cruise holidays.  Interestingly, in our past 4 cruises we were never subjected to this sort of situation – so how it can be considered to be normal – seems to counter our previous experiences.

When we returned we did some googling to see if there was any other comments about this problem.  In fact it seems this has been an ongoing issues and a number of former passengers have commented about it on various forums.  See the following critic sites which can be easily found by googling the following search string “granduer of the seas reviews”

Cruise Critic .co.uk
www.Cruise.co.uk

there are more sites which all tell a consistent story across a number of cruises by this ship.  So there seems to be little evidence that Royal Caribbean is dealing with this problem.  This is in my view a very unacceptable situation.

Onboard I filled in a complaint form and then on our return home I emailed to the “Crown and Anchor Society” to ask what address I can use to write to the Managing Director of Royal Caribbean about our experience.  My wife also filled in a lengthy survey and raised the issue of the stench – and we have had no response to any of these communcation RCI.  Four weeks have passed I have not even yet recieved an acknowledgement that my email has been received.  It would appear that Royal Caribbean’s policy when faced with complaints of this nature is to simply ignore them.

I have held of publishing this post in the hope that I would revieve a response to my email – but it seems that even the RCI loyalty club ( the Crown and Anchor Society)  does not consider that this problem warrants being acknowledged and responded to.

I am very dissappointed that we have had to endure this experience.  But even more of a concern is the lack of any response from Royal Caribbean about it.

Should people paying for a 5 star experience be subjected to the equivelant of living in the middle of a sewerage plant?  To be honest I have in the past visited a sewerage plant and the smell there was not nearly as intense as the one onboard the Grandeur of the Seas.  Perhaps the ship should be renamed “Grandstench of the Seas”

Broken Printer – working again ;-)

For some time I have had a slight ( perhaps more than slight!) issue with my HP Lasetjet 2605 printer.  Basically, the red colours seemed to be faded and more like yellow.  I replaced the cartridges but still the same issue.  The printer is now about 4.5 years old so I expected the worst.  I phoned the HP technical help line to be told that the printer is no longer supported.

I did a search on Google and found the following article which explains in some detail how to fix this very problem.

Click here to view

Result – followed the instructions and my printer is now as good as new.  The process took about 1.5 hours of patient instruction following……